跳到正文
Phys.org·· 6 天前AI 评分22

财报电话会议的透明度并不保证信息平等获取

Transparency in earnings calls does not guarantee equal access to information

AI 导读

Kaisa Penttinen 的博士论文分析 7 家公司财报

AI 深度导读基于原文整理的分节解读
背景
上市公司对外沟通长期以书面财报为主,而书面文件是从公司自身视角编制、并受法律要求约束的。财报电话会上的问答环节在上市公司的公开沟通中属于相对较新的现象,直到21世纪初才与书面披露一起确立下来。问答环节的价值在于它允许参与者就信息本身进行「协商」:可以调整披露的详细程度,也能拿到不完整、未结构化、尚未定型的信息。但这类环节是否真的让投资判断变容易,此前并不清楚:分析师与高管使用的专业语言,可能把讨论推到听众无法完全跟上的层次。Penttinen 的研究正是在这一背景下,切入当前关于金融市场透明度与信息可靠传播的讨论。
做法
这是芬兰瓦萨大学会计学的一篇博士论文,作者 Kaisa Penttinen,论文题为《Financial Communication in Earnings Calls: Disclosure Practices in the Q&A》,收入 Acta Wasaensia 592 系列,已于 2026 年 9 月 11 日(周五)公开答辩。研究材料是纳斯达克赫尔辛基交易所上市的共七家公司财报电话会中问答部分的转写稿,方法为话语分析(discourse analysis)。分析的核心不是问答里说了哪些数字,而是双方如何在互动中处理信息:分析师如何提问、管理层如何组织回答、详细程度如何被临时调整,以及问答与受法律约束的书面披露之间处在什么位置。研究者关注的具体判定点包括:分析师的问题是否指涉此前与公司管理层在私下会面中讨论过的内容;管理层是否回避或模糊回答、是否用长期视角回应本意指向短期的问题;分析师是否会提出对抗性问题、或抛出自己的结论以促使管理层就其准确性表态。这一路径与只考察书面披露的研究不同,把口头、即兴、双向的沟通本身当作分析对象。
结论
在七家芬兰上市公司的问答转写稿中,研究得到的结果是分层的。一方面,问答环节确实提供了书面报告之外的有用信息:由于口头沟通比受法律要求约束的书面披露更自由,高管能更即兴地组织回答,问答因此可能带出此前未公开的信息。另一方面,这并不等于信息平等可达。研究者指出,当分析师的问题引用此前与公司管理层在私下会面中讨论过的内容时,听众可能难以解读这段交流;分析师与高管使用的专业语言也可能把讨论抬到听众无法完全理解的层次,投资者或许需要自行做更多背景功课才能跟上问答。问答中还可见分析师与管理层之间的张力:高管可能回避或模糊回答,或用长期视角回答短期问题;分析师则首要目标是取得支撑知情投资决策的信息,为拿到关键信息有时必须提出对抗性问题,也会给出自己的结论以促使管理层评论其准确性。管理层的常见处理方式不是沉默,而是向听众说明公司为何不便评论,例如出于竞争原因。
机制
作者给出的解释落在两种沟通渠道的约束差异上。书面披露受法律要求约束,措辞经过设计;问答环节的沟通更自由,高管可以更即兴地组织答案,因此既有更多信息流出的空间,也留下了回避、模糊和答非所问的空间。分析师一侧的动力结构同样解释了问答的形态:他们需要与公司维持建设性的关系,但又必须拿到对投资判断至关重要的信息,两种目标并存时,对抗性提问和主动亮出自身结论就成了可选手段。听众理解的困难,则来自问答所依托的语境——包括分析师与公司管理层在私下会面中已经形成的讨论——并不对在场所有听众开放。
意义
这项研究把「透明」与「平等获取信息」拆开来看:管理层公开露面本身会强化开放与透明的印象,但问答环节的实际可理解性取决于语言层次和参与者共享的语境。对个人投资者,这意味着财报电话会是可以用的信息源,但可能需要额外的背景研究;对公司,分析师的双向提问有价值,因为它让公司更清楚分析师如何评估公司表现。研究也接入当前关于金融市场透明度与可靠信息传播的讨论。
局限
研究结论建立在纳斯达克赫尔辛基七家上市公司问答部分转写稿的话语分析之上,样本数量与市场范围都很有限,结论向其他市场或其他规模公司的外推没有在正文中给出依据。分析材料限于转写稿这一文本形式。
正文 · 原文
q and a
Credit: Leeloo The First from Pexels

The specialized language used by analysts and management in listed companies' Q&A sessions can be challenging for individual investors to follow. However, Kaisa Penttinen's doctoral dissertation in accounting at the University of Vaasa, Finland, shows these sessions still deliver useful information beyond what is disclosed in written reports alone.

While listed companies' financial reports are prepared purely from the companies' perspective, the Q&A sessions of earnings calls give participants the opportunity to negotiate over information, adjust the level of detail and also obtain incomplete, unstructured and unfinished information.

However, Q&A sessions do not automatically make it easier to make investment decisions.

"The professional language used by analysts and company executives can take the discussion to a level that the audience does not fully understand. It may also be beneficial for the investors to carry out further background research in order to follow the discussion in the Q&A better," says Ph.D. candidate Penttinen.

Penttinen's study suggests that the audience may have difficulty interpreting communication in Q&A sessions when analysts' questions refer to discussions previously held with company management in private meetings. On the other hand, Q&A sessions can also bring to light previously unpublished information that is useful to investors.

"In Q&A sessions, the communication of information is freer than in written disclosures, which are subject to legal requirements, and company executives can formulate their answers more spontaneously."

The study analyzed transcripts from the Q&A sections of a total of seven companies listed on Nasdaq Helsinki.

Participants negotiate over information

According to the researcher, it is positive that alongside formal reports, other channels of financial communication have also emerged. Earnings calls are a relatively new phenomenon in the public communications of listed companies, as they only became established alongside written disclosures in the early 2000s.

Penttinen's study, based on discourse analysis, shows that tensions can sometimes arise between analysts and management. The study ties in with the current discussion on transparency and reliable communication of information in financial markets.

"Company executives may, for example, seek to evade or obscure their answers, or respond to questions with a long-term perspective, even if the question was intended to concern the short term."

Analysts, on the other hand, seek above all to obtain information that supports informed investment decisions.

"Analysts wish to maintain a constructive relationship with companies, but sometimes, in order to get essential information, they need to pose confronting questions to company executives. Analysts may also, for example, present their own conclusions in order to prompt management to comment on their accuracy."

Two-way communication with analysts is valuable for companies, as it enables them to better understand how analysts assess the company's performance.

"The very fact that management appears before the public reinforces the impression of openness and transparency. Rather than remaining silent, managers often prefer to explain to the audience that the company is unwilling to comment on a particular matter, for example due to competitive reasons."

The public examination of Penttinen's doctoral dissertation "Financial Communication in Earnings Calls: Disclosure Practices in the Q&A" was held on Friday, Sept. 11, 2026.

More information

Penttinen, Kaisa (2026) Financial Communication in Earnings Calls: Disclosure Practices in the Q&A. Acta Wasaensia 592. Doctoral dissertation. University of Vaasa. urn.fi/URN:ISBN:978-952-395-286-7

Citation: Transparency in earnings calls does not guarantee equal access to information (2026, November 12) retrieved 12 November 2026 from https://phys.org/news/2026-11-transparency-equal-access.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

来源:Phys.org · phys.org